{{ 'now' | timezone: 'America/New_York' | date: '%b %d, %Y' }}
|
|
|
Greetings from Los Angeles, welcome back to In the Room, and—pending regulatory
review—kudos to everyone on the culmination of the Warner Bros. Discovery bidding war. Congrats to David Zaslav for driving the price from $7 to $31 a share (no small feat!). Congrats to David Ellison on finally getting his coveted prize (hope it was worth it!). Congrats to Ted Sarandos for exercising fiscal discipline and overextending a competitor’s debt obligations (chef’s kiss). And congrats to my partner Bill
Cohan for seeing all this coming.
So… Does Bari Weiss get CNN? The Skydance team is too busy popping bottles to discuss that right now, but the decades-old dream of a united CNN–CBS News could finally become a reality. Bari’s early missteps may have handicapped her shot at the bigger assignment, and a merger might even open the
door for a role recalibration, but given the state of the field, what’s the alternative? As you know, everyone in Hudson Yards is wetting their pants.
In tonight’s issue, I’ve got fresh reporting on the Bari chatter, the panic at CNN, and what the merger portends for both networks. Plus, some scoops on Mathias Döpfner’s plans for Politico as he courts candidates for the top editor role—and mulls a change in the chief executive’s office as well…
I’m off to
Santa Barbara for the weekend, then heading to Washington for Puck’s fourth annual First Amendment Gala at the French Ambassador’s Residence. This year’s guest of honor is the incomparable Andrew Ross Sorkin. This is always a swell, high-spirited event and, for my money, D.C.’s best party of the year. I look forward to seeing many of you there.
🎙️ Plus, on the latest episode of The Grill Room, Julia Alexander and I dove into the new
partnership between Polymarket and Substack, and debated whether live markets actually make journalism better. We also assessed the latest turbulence at The Washington Post and addressed the existential question: Is there anything Jeff Bezos can realistically do to steady the ship? Follow The Grill Room on Apple,
Spotify, or wherever you prefer to listen.
Also mentioned in this issue: Goli Sheikholeslami, Justin Smith, Jeff Zucker, John Harris, Steven Ginsberg, Fred
Ryan, Ezra Klein, Rupert Murdoch, Kara Swisher, Alisyn Camerota, Cameron Barr, Sally Buzbee, Anderson Cooper, David Rhodes, Jan Bayer, Claudius Senst, Peter Spiegel, Julie Pace, James Bennet, Alex Burns, and more…
|
Things You Should Know...
|
-
Ginsberg’s revenge: The Athletic editor Steven Ginsberg has hired six of the Washington Post journalists who were laid off after the paper shuttered its sports page—a ruthlessly efficient land grab that will establish The New York Times’s sports vertical as the market leader in D.C. more or less overnight. “For many decades, The Washington Post was the go-to place for sports for Washingtonians,” Ginsberg told
Axios. “That’s not an option now, and we want to make sure that people understand that The Athletic can be one.”
Yes, the move underscores the delta between the Times’s success and the Post’s struggles, but also the divergence of their business models. The Times is leveraging The Athletic as a subscription flywheel in local markets—and in this case, especially, converting civic pride into recurring revenue—whereas the Post is retrenching to
effectively focus on one vertical: Official Washington (which, as you know, is already a heavily saturated and competitive market).
There’s an additional subplot here: Ginsberg is a longtime Post veteran who decamped to the Times after former publisher Fred Ryan passed him over for the top editor job. (He also passed over Cameron Barr.) Fred gave it to Sally Buzbee instead, of course—one of many mile
markers on the Post’s long slide into irrelevance. - You get a TBPN!: Fortune is searching for a showrunner to lead a new daily business show—the latest example of news orgs looking to build live programming amid the industry’s broader embrace of video. Live shows offer recurring touchpoints with
audiences and sponsor-friendly inventory, to be sure. But, as I never tire of noting, they also demand an entirely different skill set. One among them: the ability to finesse ink-stained journalists into camera-ready video stars. To date, the success stories—such as Ezra at the Times—are few and far between.
- And finally…: Netflix is releasing a four-part docuseries on Rupert Murdoch that charts his rise from
Fleet Street to Fox and his children’s recent battle to control his empire. Some faces you’ll recognize in the film: Kara Swisher, Alisyn Camerota, The Atlantic’s McKay Coppins, and the Times’s Jim Rutenberg and Jonathan Mahler. The series, titled Dynasty: The Murdochs, debuts on March 13.
|
“We do not operate in countries where the freedom of expression, freedom of media, and the rule of
law and human rights do not exist. … We would not invest in China for example, or other non-democratic countries.” —Axel Springer C.E.O. Mathias Döpfner, onstage at a Semafor event, one day after Semafor’s Justin Smith launched a new vertical in China.
And now, the main event…
|
|
|
The WBD–PSKY post-merger dread hit CNN immediately yesterday, as its journalists
and producers pondered life under Bari—but only if her CBS misfires haven’t disqualified her from running the combined operation. Plus, the voracious Mathias Döpfner’s global talent hunt.
|
|
|
“Well, fuck,” one CNN journalist texted me after it became clear on Thursday evening that
David Ellison was poised to secure Warner Bros. Discovery. The news, precipitated by Netflix’s decision to abandon its pursuit of the asset, immediately catalyzed a Cat-5 freakout among many of the network’s journalists, and for myriad reasons. A Paramount Skydance takeover—yes, pending regulatory approval—is likely to usher in historic layoffs across the company that will further diminish an already beleaguered newsroom. It will also mark the third ownership
change in less than a decade. And both David and his father, Larry, have signaled their intention to make their news outlets more conservative.
Looming above all this, of course, is the prospect that Bari Weiss may now expand her editorial remit at CBS News to CNN, as well. “The panic at CNN right now is off the charts,”
one network veteran said. Another, alluding to the companywide trauma that shook the network after the unceremonious defenestration of Jeff Zucker, in 2022, told me: “My phone has not blown up this bad, with this level of fury and sadness, since JZ got canned.”
In truth, it’s premature to assume that Bari will be given the same control over CNN that she now has over CBS News. And as some of these CNN employees lurch for their beta blockers and vodka, they might even
recall that JZ is now an investor and operating partner at RedBird Capital, the Ellisons’ partner in the $111 billion deal. But why allow cooler heads to prevail—especially because that expansive CNN–CBS News mandate was certainly the initial plan that David floated during his courtship, before her early turbulence at CBS may have altered the trajectory. Bari’s quick missteps have emphasized
the vertical learning curve between running a Substack-based business and managing a broadcast news network. Leading a global, 24-hour cable news channel is obviously a whole different order of magnitude.
That said, a merger would certainly expand Bari’s sphere of influence. Successive generations of executives have entertained a CNN–CBS News tie-up for at
least three decades, and there is no world in which the Ellisons wouldn’t unite the two news divisions under one banner, given the mandate for cost savings. (The Ellisons have suggested the synergies lie in the $6 billion range; the Netflix board put the number at $16 billion. Either way, that’s a lot of pink slips.) In any scenario, Bari would almost certainly serve as the spiritual guide for the combined newsroom's politics and editorial posture, if not necessarily given the same
authority to dictate every programming and personnel decision. At the very least, she and Anderson will have another chance to hash out their differences—one of the many intriguing sub-subplots.
The big question, of course, is who actually gets to run the network. Mark Thompson, the existing CNN chairman and
C.E.O., is unlikely to stick around for the Ellison era, I’m told. But, as the history of both CBS and CNN has shown, the bench of capable television news executives has grown quite thin. Zucker’s politics certainly don’t align. One imagines the Ellisons will put in another call to David Rhodes, the former CBS News president who now runs Sky News in the U.K. At present, the Skydance team is too busy popping champagne corks to think about any of this.
|
In recent weeks, Mathias Döpfner, the imposing C.E.O. of Axel Springer, has been
spotted with his charges in various hotel lobbies in Manhattan and Washington, spurring all manner of gossip among media insiders who perennially wonder whom he might hire or what he may acquire. Mathias has courted the intrigue, expressing a restive desire to acquire media assets in the pages of The Wall Street Journal, mounting a possibly quixotic eleventh-hour
bid for The Telegraph, and, most notably, instigating an overhaul of Politico, the flagship U.S. asset of a transatlantic media business that, he hopes, can one day become the leading light for the democratic world.
Mathias and his top deputies, Jan Bayer and Claudius Senst, have met with candidates for the top editorial job at Politico, where founding editor-in-chief and paterfamilias John Harris is poised to
finally vacate the chair. As I reported weeks ago, Mathias & Co. have met with Washington Post managing editor Peter Spiegel, Associated Press executive editor Julie Pace, and former New York Times editorial page editor James Bennet to discuss the position. Mathias also met with Politico senior executive editor Alex Burns, though it’s unclear whether that was the start of a real overture.
The editor
search, however, may actually belie the true scope of Mathias’s ambitions for Politico. While this hunt has been underway, I’m told that Mathias, Jan, and Claudius have also been meeting with various business executives across the industry, sparking internal speculation that they might also be mulling replacing Politico C.E.O. Goli Sheikholeslami.
Jan, the president of Springer’s U.S. media arm, flatly denied that there were any plans to replace Goli. “Any
speculation about questioning Goli or our confidence in her leadership is untrue,” he told me. Instead, Jan characterized the meetings as routine introductions with executives. “We are active in 25 countries, and of course we are meeting with industry leaders in the U.S., in Germany, in Poland… We’ve never talked about a replacement of one of our C.E.O.s,” he said. “It’s just to build our network.”
Two sources with indirect knowledge of the meetings asserted that this narrative was merely
cover for talent scouting. At the very least, Mathias certainly seems new-C.E.O.-curious. Politico may be the bright spot in the Springer portfolio, with around $250 million in annual revenue and healthy 20 percent profit margins, but it’s also true that the business is stagnating as the available pool of Pro subscribers hits a ceiling. The most well-informed estimates I’ve heard suggest that Politico draws about a third of its revenue from its consumer advertising business and
two-thirds from its high-priced annual recurring revenue subscription business. And though the business is profitable, a recent restructuring that laid off 3 percent of employees suggests some headwinds.
For all its success, Politico certainly does not match the scope of Mathias’s ambitions—not on the editorial side, where it has suffered years of spiritual ennui, nor on the business side. The business will likely need to get acquisitive in order to continue growing—though, as Mathias
himself has pointed out, there aren’t a lot of compelling assets on the market…
|
|
|
Puck founding partner Matt Belloni takes you inside the business of Hollywood, using exclusive reporting and insight
to explain the backstories on everything from Marvel movies to the streaming wars.
|
|
|
Unique and privileged insight into the private conversations taking place inside boardrooms and corner offices up and
down Wall Street, relayed by best-selling author, journalist, and former M&A senior banker William D. Cohan.
|
|
|
|
|
MATTHEW BELLONI & WILLIAM D. COHAN
|
|
|
Need help? Review our FAQ page or contact us for assistance. For brand partnerships, email ads@puck.news. You received this email because you
signed up to receive emails from Puck, or as part of your Puck account associated with {{customer.email}}. To stop receiving this newsletter and/or manage all your email preferences, click here.
|
Puck is published by Heat Media LLC. 107 Greenwich St., New York, NY 10006
|
|
|
|