Welcome back to The Varsity. I’m John Ourand, coming to you
live from San Francisco, where reports are saying that neither Robert Kraft nor Bill Belichick received enough votes for the Hall of Fame in their first year of eligibility. This should make Thursday’s Hall announcement a must-watch. In other news, the brutal layoffs coming to The
Washington Post will start tomorrow, per my partner Dylan Byers. Read our piece from last week to understand why my hometown paper is moving away from covering sports.
Meanwhile, congrats to Josh D’Amaro,
Disney’s next C.E.O. It’s hard to draw any immediate conclusions about how ESPN will be affected, but Bristol insiders are encouraged by the fact that D’Amaro and Jimmy Pitaro, who will report to him, have a good relationship. Plus, D’Amaro has made it known that he’s a big sports fan, even if he is from Boston. (D’Amaro graduated from Georgetown in 1993, right at the end of the Alonzo Mourning era.) ESPN’s potential spinoff from the
parentco will be a storyline to watch in the early days of the D’Amaro regime. Those rumors are still around, and the idea is still on the table. But D’Amaro hasn’t given any indication about whether he supports it or not.
In today’s issue, Julia Alexander dives into what’s expected to be a meaningful month for Peacock, which will share NBC’s broadcast rights to the Winter Olympics, Super Bowl, and NBA All-Star Game. The embattled streamer, which is mired at 44 million
subscribers, needs to leverage this moment to prove out its value. So what is NBCU doing to make sure all those new subscribers stick around? Julia’s must-read columns are available only to our Inner Circle subscribers. Click here to upgrade—it’s worth it.
Also mentioned in this issue: Bad Bunny, Roger Goodell, Neal Mohan,
Tomàs-Llorenç Guarino Sabaté, Donna Langley, Christian Genetski, Tyler “Ninja” Blevins, and many more…
Take it away, Julia…
|
Stat of the Week: $36,000
|
That’s the current pool on Polymarket, give or take a few hundred bucks, for whether Bad
Bunny will say “F- ICE” during his halftime performance at the Super Bowl. Over on Kalshi, there’s $2.8 million riding on what his first song will be. Anyway, Bad Bunny isn’t the only musician potentially worrying Roger Goodell: Bay Area legends Green Day, who have also been incredibly vocal in their disdain for the Trump administration, are set to open the game. If I’m Goodell, I’d start preparing for a potential phone call from the president. Maybe
he’ll luck out and just get a Truth Social post instead.
|
- Google’s hidden figures: We know that a lot of people are watching a lot of YouTube, but what they’re watching has never been totally clear… and Google is seemingly trying to keep it that way. Its legal team recently issued a cease-and-desist letter to Barb, a Nielsen equivalent in the U.K., as well as market research firm Kantar to get them to stop scraping its viewership data following an initial report from both companies that analyzed the most-watched
channels on the platform across TV sets in the region. Google reportedly objected to Kantar’s measurement attribution system for individual creators, arguing it violated YouTube’s terms of service and creator A.P.I.s. (In the past, YouTube has said that it supports third-party research, but aims to protect creators’ rights.)
Obviously, analysts and competitors would love unfettered access to YouTube’s viewership information. But it’s also particularly important to advertisers. After all,
C.E.O. Neal Mohan has spent the last few years touting the importance of TV to YouTube’s business, and U.S. viewers now watch more than a billion hours of the platform’s content on the boob tube every day, according to the company. But while Netflix, Disney, Paramount, NBCUniversal, Amazon, and even Apple allow third-party measurement firms to dig into granular viewership data for advertisers, Google is still throwing up roadblocks. - An
Olympics copyright caper: I always expect a little drama ahead of an Olympics (here’s hoping those ice rinks are fully frozen!), but a copyright issue impacting Spanish figure skater Tomàs-Llorenç Guarino Sabaté may be this year’s highlight. Sabaté became an online sensation thanks to his unusual costume of blue overalls and yellow shirt, and a routine set to a song from the Despicable Me and Minions movies. But now he’s been told that he can’t
use the track for his upcoming performance due to copyright issues. On Instagram, he posted a note saying it’s “incredibly disappointing,” but that he’ll face “this challenge head-on” entering the Games.
Of course this seems rapturously silly, but the song (and, yes, the outfit) helped Sabaté find viral fame despite finishing 18th in the European Figure Skating Championships in Sheffield, England. The International Skating Union has even had to put out a statement, noting that “copyright
clearances can represent a challenge for all artistic sports.” As NBCU tries to build hype around the Games, perhaps Donna Langley could intervene? - FanDuel’s e-sports gambling boomlet: On a recent Sports Business Journal podcast episode, FanDuel Group president Christian Genetski discussed some of the trends he’s been seeing as betting becomes more popular across the country. Notably, he said that
e-sports—including professional FIFA, Madden, and Call of Duty leagues—are enjoying hockey-stick-like growth from a dedicated base. He noted that this particular segment of bettors remains engaged given the “always-on” component to e-sports, and that “you’ve got a lot of people in the prime sports betting age who grew up playing NBA2K and other games.”
While e-sports have long been popular, they’ve never really broken into the mainstream. In
fact, they very well seemed to peak around 2021, following an uptick in popular games like Fortnite and players like Tyler “Ninja” Blevins. Twitch, the most popular e-sports platform, also has a fraction of YouTube’s audience. But the rise of betting might reinvigorate the appetite for a subgenre of sports entertainment that, less than a decade ago, seemed like the future.
|
|
|
NBC is expecting droves of new subscribers ahead of a trifecta of major sports
events: the Super Bowl, Winter Olympics, and the NBA All-Star Game. Now it just needs to keep them.
|
|
|
Over at 30 Rock, the Peacock brain trust is buzzing about what they’re calling “Legendary
February”—the planetary alignment of the Super Bowl, the Olympic Games, and the NBA All-Star Game. NBCU executives have placed huge bets on live sports to power the streamer’s subscription engine, premised on the notion that customers who sign up for tentpole events will stick around after. But Legendary February will be a critical test of whether that thesis bears out. Peacock, after all, is the one major streamer that has yet to turn a profit (thanks in part to its $2.5
billion-per-year NBA deal…), and it has struggled to surpass 45 million subscribers or 2 percent of total TV viewing time in the past year, per Nielsen. Even worse, while Peacock’s losses had started to narrow over the past several quarters, Comcast just reported a $552 million loss on the streamer—largely driven by those sports ambitions.
Still, sports remains one of the few major levers that NBCUniversal’s team has left to get better subscriber traction. The Paris
Olympics were particularly instructive. According to reports at the time, Peacock added some 2.8 million customers during the first week of the Games, and more than 75 percent of new customers who signed up for the Games remained subscribed after 30 days. By the 90-day mark, however, that percentage had fallen to 60 percent, according to NBCU sources. By the end of the first year, about 45 percent remained. So while sports have helped address one of Peacock’s biggest top-of-funnel awareness
problems, NBCU hasn’t yet cracked the secondary problem of retention.
Streaming executives partially measure the value of sports programming by assessing how many non-sports titles a new subscriber watches within 30 days of signing up. More than 80 percent of new customers who signed up due to the Paris Olympics, for example, watched five or more non-Olympics titles within their first 30 days, according to a source. That’s a strong figure on its own, but obviously, many of those
subscribers didn’t find enough engaging secondary content to keep them from canceling over the following year.
Meanwhile, the streamer’s other sports bets have yielded mixed results. Fans of the WWE, whose rights Peacock acquired for $1 billion some five years ago (the deal expired in December), never watched much else outside of fight night. However, the NBA seems to be driving meaningful engagement to other titles—most notably Twisted Metal, the Anthony
Mackie–led adaptation of the popular PlayStation franchise, according to sources inside the company. And unlike the Olympics, the NBA spans nine months of the year. It’s still early days for the partnership, but the league seems to be performing more like the Premier League or the NFL in its ability to drive large cohorts of mainstream audiences to non-sports content on Peacock.
|
Of course, investing billions of dollars in these sports means that hundreds of
other scripted and unscripted shows might not get made—an interesting paradox for executives. Love Island, for example, brought in a massive wave of new Gen Z subscribers to Peacock at a fraction of the cost of more-traditional programming. But that audience has not proven reliable: The show’s many spinoffs never captured that same viral engagement. So while the NBA investment likely means fewer scripted and unscripted shows will appear on the platform, executives are betting that the
NBA, which averaged about 2.7 million views on ABC last year, can bring in a reliable audience each week.
In other words, tonnage still matters. In a streaming ecosystem where subscribers are quick to cancel their memberships, that level of predictability is invaluable. It seems to be working, too: On-platform engagement among NBA viewers increased by 370 percent in the 30 days after Peacock aired its first game, according to Antenna, compared to non-NBA viewers, whose engagement
increased by 87 percent in the same time frame.
Yet it’s also hard to imagine Peacock would be better off without its marquee sports franchises, which have become its signature differentiator. With less than a seventh of Netflix’s subscriber base, Peacock arguably needs the NBA, the Premier League, the Olympics, and the NFL. But there’s no question it’s an expensive approach for a streamer that has yet to turn a profit… at least until David Ellison comes
calling.
|
Thanks, Julia. See you all on Thursday,
John
|
|
|
Puck sports correspondent John Ourand and a rotating cast of industry insiders take you inside the executive suites
and owners boxes where the decisions that shape the entire sports business are made. You’ll hear interviews with players, network execs, and everyone in between. The Varsity is an extension of John’s private email for Puck by the same name. New episodes publish every Wednesday and Sunday.
|
|
|
Ace media reporter Dylan Byers brings readers into the C-suite as he chronicles the biggest stories in the industry:
the future of cable news in the streaming era, the transformation of legacy publishers, the tech giants remaking the market, and all the egos involved.
|
|
|
Need help? Review our
FAQ page or contact us for assistance. For brand partnerships, email ads@puck.news.
You received this email because you signed up to receive emails from Puck, or as part of your Puck account associated with {{customer.email}}. To stop receiving this newsletter and/or manage all your email preferences, click here.
|
Puck is published by Heat Media LLC. 107 Greenwich St., New York, NY 10006
|
|
|
|