Vance Sanewashing, Walz Nerves & The January 6 Knockout

JD Vance And Tim Walz v.p. debate
I think the consensus is loosely that J.D. Vance proved himself to be a more able debater, a guy who went to Yale Law School and who could be a podcaster in another life. Photo: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images
John Heilemann
&
Peter Hamby
October 3, 2024

In keeping with Puck’s newest grand tradition, in the small hours following last night’s very Midwestern showdown between veep contenders J.D. Vance and Tim Walz, Puck partners John Heilemann, Dylan Byers, and Peter Hamby huddled up to break down the evening’s most pertinent plot points: how the moderators actually fared, Vance’s fluent and slippery outing, Walz’s second-half comeback, and much, much more. Their timely debate recap was featured, in full, on both Impolitic and The Powers That Be podcasts, which you can listen to here or here. The following conversation has been lightly edited for length and clarity.