Hi, and welcome to Line Sheet, reporting live from New York City, forever relieved that I didn’t
have to go to Miami for Art Basel.
I’ll be out and about this week and hope to see you somewhere. In today’s issue, I’m gaming out some scenarios over at LVMH—the dust has settled on the designer switcharoos, but there are executive changes planned for the early part of the new year. As I’ve said before, there’s really no point in seriously talking about succession at this juncture—three of Bernard Arnault’s five adult children are under 35, and he’s
clearly signaled that he plans to remain in power for the foreseeable future. And yet decisions are being rendered that would seem to position the company for the world beyond. Also: Up top, a little bit on the battle Luca Guadagnino inexplicably picked with the costume design community, notes on Chanel’s decision to make A$AP Rocky an ambassador, and an analysis of the new Armani board composition.
Tomorrow on Fashion
People, my guest is world-renowned cook, Sézane lover, and Substack defector Alison Roman, whose new book, Something From Nothing, is available now. We evaluate the fashion on Landman (our favorite show), Guadagnino’s disdain for costume designers (it’s so funny), holiday party outfits, and plenty more. Listen
here and here.
Mentioned in this issue: Jonathan Anderson, Dior, Maria Grazia Chiuri, Fendi, Kim Jones, Bernard Arnault, LVMH, Michael Burke,
Pietro Beccari, Louis Vuitton, Damien Bertrand, Murakami, Frédéric Arnault, Loro Piana, Luca Guadagnino, A$AP Rocky, Matthieu Blazy, Chanel, Armani, Sofia Coppola, and many more…
|
Three Things You
Should Know…
|
- Luca
versus the costume department: Last week, a small corner of the Oscar-voting internet went ablaze following the release of a clip featuring Luca Guadagnino dragging the cinematic costume design community. “Costume designers, and I’m gonna create enemies here, tend to think in terms of the garment. Designers of fashion think in terms of the body, who wears them,” he told Tim Blanks, one of my favorite people in the world, at Business of
Fashion’s recent conference. “That is what makes costume design from people like Jonathan [Anderson] or in my collaborations with Raf [Simons] or Giulia Piersanti [who designed knits for Phoebe Philo at Céline], it’s that you eventually can find the character and the person, not just the character.” Time to clench your teeth.
Look, I am a huge fan of the
way that Guadagnino uses fashion in his movies; he obviously loves it in the same way that many of us do. However, I don’t think he’s exactly right here. There are plenty of costume designers who “think in terms of the body”: Nancy Steiner, who did everything from Lost in Translation to Promising Young Woman, is a great example; so is Stacey Battat, who has done Sofia Coppola’s
more recent movies. And, as one fashion historian noted to me, two of Alexander McQueen’s biggest influences were Travis Banton and Adrian.
Anyway, I’m not sure why he chose to say such a goofy thing. Guadagnino should have just said he likes working with fashion designers because they are cooler than costume designers, which is usually the case, unless you’re talking about Colleen
Atwood, who is very cool. It’s just a very shallow way to think about it—which I guess is reflective of Guadagnino, not the designers? (In other Tim Blanks news, there are tons of episodes of Fashion File newly posted to YouTube. Enjoy!)
|
|
|
A MESSAGE FROM OUR SPONSOR
|
The refined BMW 7 Series is all luxury. With the ability to define your design, the ultimate glamour is yet to be.
Learn more at BMWUSA.com.
|
|
|
- The
A$AP ambassadorship: I assumed that cutie pie A$AP Rocky’s Chanel ambassadorship had already been announced, given that he has been wearing Chanel around town (to the CFDA Awards) and was caught filming a Michel Gondry–directed commercial with Margaret Qualley. Well, it’s official now, just in time for the brand’s Métiers d’art show, which happens tomorrow in New York City. (More to come later this week.)
Does this
mean that Matthieu Blazy will indeed launch Chanel menswear, now that his buddy Rocky is officially on board and Pedro Pascal is bopping around in Chanel, too? Chanel execs have repeatedly said they have no plans to launch a separate men’s collection. My guess is that it will happen some day, but maybe they also don’t need to: Chanel sells men’s cologne, and many guys already shop Chanel ready-to-wear and accessories. Anyway,
there’s no rush. - Armani gets the Bizzarri treatment: The Giorgio Armani board has expanded now that the company is getting ready to sell a portion of the business. New board members include former Ralph Lauren and Armani executive John Hooks, as well as Angelo Moratti, founder of Angel Capital Management, an investment firm with a portfolio that includes Isamaya Ffrench’s beauty line,
Allbirds, Rhode, Princi, Naadam, Dolls Kill, FabFitFun, M.Gemi, Our Place, and Deliveroo. (Very American-y.) And there’s Marco Bizzarri, former Gucci C.E.O., beloved Italian luxury executive. They’re all notable: Moratti is a startup guy, Hooks worked at Armani for a long time, and Bizzarri has experience professionalizing and scaling entrenched Italian companies. Exciting stuff.
|
Now, for the main event...
|
|
|
At LVMH, a series of anticipated executive shuffles may suggest the latest contours of a
succession strategy. At the very least, it’s got the industry kremlinologists taking notice.
|
|
|
Everyone keeps asking me how it’s going with Jonathan Anderson at Dior. And
I keep answering that it’s hard to tell thus far. It’s been six months. Very little of the product is in stores, and very early indicators suggest that Q4 luxury retail results will be soft in the U.S., where it seems like everyone is buying Gap pajamas and skincare. Then there are Anderson’s natural growing pains as he ascends from Loewe, which he transformed into a platform for his own unique talent, to a truly historic and code-driven brand—not to mention decidedly commercial—like
Dior.
Of course, there will be customer attrition at his Dior, at least at first: On the women’s side, Maria Grazia Chiuri’s devoted clientele will migrate with her to Fendi; and somewhere on the men’s side, too. (There is a group of GLP-1-avoidant menswear customers who really love Kim Jones’s figure-flattering styles.) I’m confident that the Bar jacket in a Donegal tweed, which Anderson showed
prominently during men’s pre-fall, can become a coveted, high-ticket item. Overall, though, I’ve heard mixed things from clients: Some are charmed, others feel that everything Anderson is offering—the slim chinos, deliberately tacky belts, worn jeans—can be found elsewhere, and continue to take a more hesitant, wait-and-see approach.
If Anderson is creating the best version of standards, they will sell. (I like the branded sweats a lot.) And that seems to be part of a strategy that is
less concerned with the old ways of luxury—buying for the hype and the sake of buying—and more interested in tiny, beautiful things. Anderson’s recent Instagram posts featured pages of jewelry and material details, which may appeal to a different kind of customer. While Anderson’s success is going to rely heavily on support in China, it’s important to remember that there are dozens of different consumer segments within the region. The old customers may leave, but there are,
hypothetically, ample new ones to replace them. At least that’s the plan, but it underscores my own hesitancy to render a preemptive verdict. When I know more, you will know.
|
|
|
A MESSAGE FROM OUR SPONSOR
|
The refined BMW 7 Series is all luxury. With the ability to define your design, the ultimate glamour is yet to be.
Learn more at BMWUSA.com.
|
|
|
Meanwhile, I’m currently more interested in the movement at the LVMH group level, where questions abound
about the ever-deliberated standing of some of Bernard Arnault’s longtime, near-retired deputies. What do their current and future deployments indicate about the long-term management of the company? And, of course, what does all this mean for the next generation? After all, LVMH shares are creeping back upward after a severe dip earlier this year, with support from analysts who have, for the most part, rated it outperform.
|
The installment of Michael Burke in the U.S. over the summer was ostensibly
the first step in a bigger plan to move executives around and out. But Burke was already “out of the game,” as his last two years were described to me by senior leadership, so his appointment had few consequences for those working in Europe. At present, the biggest question mark is around the future of Pietro Beccari,
the current C.E.O. of Louis Vuitton, who has expressed interest in moving back to Italy. (They always move back, eventually.)
One prominent theory across various parts of the business is that deputy C.E.O. Damien Bertrand, who did well at Loro Piana, will be moved into the lead position sooner rather than later. Bertrand is ambitious and well liked, and it’s unlikely that he would have accepted the deputy job unless he considered the top gig in sight. Of
course, 2026 isn’t going to be easy. Louis Vuitton has fared relatively well compared to others in the LVMH portfolio, thanks to perennial product and retail novelties, like the Shanghai store built to look like a ship. But Beccari and Bertrand will also have to enact a plan to replicate the sales of the Murakami collaboration revival, which saved their first half of this year.
Anyway, a popular internal theory posits that Beccari may be headed back to Italy to replace
Toni Belloni, who moved there a few years back in a role similar to the one created for Burke in the U.S. While he may have had his sights set on Armani over the summer, Beccari’s primary mission would likely be to train and support the 30-year-old Frédéric Arnault, whose gig as C.E.O. of Loro Piana is
growing more expansive by the hour. The cashmere mill, which LVMH acquired more than a decade ago, has become the leading model of the modern LVMH acquisition playbook: It has a specific material expertise, and LVMH shaped it into a modern brand via world-class marketing, image-making, and distribution. Now, it’s one of the most important names in the fashion portfolio, third only to Louis Vuitton and Dior.
Is Frédéric’s appointment at Loro Piana a harbinger that he might replace his
father a decade from now? I don’t want to disappoint LVMH kremlinologists, but his fate is a known unknown. Anyone familiar with the family psychology understands that Arnault père may slightly favor some of his kids over the others, but he’s sent each of them on a unique odyssey to test their leadership and strategic capabilities, and the most capable will likely earn the throne with minimal dispute. Some might argue that this explains why Arnault asked the board to remove age
limits on the C.E.O. role for the next decade—and that the move might favor his younger children. Moreover, that cohort would surely insist that Frédéric is currently perched in the catbird seat, especially given Beccari’s hypothetical tutelage.
|
My longstanding theory is that this isn’t going to be a reprise of the messy and personal
Murdoch situation. And, anyway, there are too many variables to predict any sure outcome. Alexandre, the middle Arnault child, was given what is arguably the more difficult job—attempting to turn around the dragging wine and spirits division, which the family insists they will never spin off.
|
|
|
In the end, different Arnaults will likely run different parts of the group, especially as
Delphine and Antoine, the eldest of the brood, settle into their respective domains. There is speculation within the group that Antoine, who oversees marketing and communications, will be awarded a seat with the executive committee, a highly prestigious position as a close advisor to his father, but also something of a sinecure. Meanwhile, Delphine’s future at Dior will largely depend on the multibillion-euro question of Anderson’s performance,
but what she wants to do with the rest of her time at LVMH will also be taken into consideration.
There is, of course, still a question about who will oversee the Fashion Group—including Loro Piana, Celine, and Loewe—given that Sidney Toledano’s position there is relatively temporary. (As one executive said to me recently, not only did the company not communicate clearly about Burke’s exit from the role, but they never said anything about Toledano’s
return.) I’m told that there will be more developments on this front in the new year. Now that the designers are all in place, someone else has to try to make it work in the face of a new reality.
|
Best dressed at Le Bal des Débutantes was definitely Princess Eugenia von Hohenzollern in
Natan, but I also enjoyed Carolina Lansing wearing her grandmother Carolina Herrera’s polka dots. Very fun. [Vogue]
Adrian González-Cohen and David Uzquiza, the editors of Buffalo Zine, share what it’s like to attempt to fund and make a magazine in 2025.
[1 Granary]
A list of the 50 best clothing stores in the country. I’m sure you’ll have quibbles, but it’s honestly very well done. Many of my personal favorites, from Plain Goods to Noodle Stories, are repped here. [New York
Times]
For me, the holidays are Metropolitan and When Harry Met Sally. Becky Malinsky, my good friend who just encouraged me to buy a red jacket with black piping from the ’80s from a vintage shop in San Francisco, appears to agree! (Go to No/Nowhere.) I cannot wait to go to parties this year. [5 Things You Need to
Buy]
If you were hoping that the Prada Group would buy your company, it’s unlikely to happen during the next two to three years while they work on fixing Versace, according to baller C.E.O. Andrea Guerra. [Bloomberg]
Everyone I know who skis (and is also chic) is very
into the Nike x Jacquemus gear. [Nike]
The owner of Miss Universe has been charged with drugs, arms, and fuel trafficking! [People]
A friend of mine who
can be kinda mean (can’t we all?) was saying the other day how much he likes Human Made. Nice to see that the Nigo-founded streetwear label, which went public last week, was up 13 percent on its first day of trading on the Tokyo Stock Exchange. [BoF]
Every day I wake up wishing for the return of the Concorde.
[Air Mail]
Do you like shoes shaped like potatoes? Is this Jacob Gallagher’s magnum opus? [New York Times]
Tom Stoppard loved women, and women loved
Tom Stoppard. They also love Ethan Hawke reading Tom Stoppard. R.I.P.! [Instagram]
|
Until tomorrow,
Lauren
P.S.: We use affiliate links because we are a business. We may
make a couple bucks off them.
|
|
|
Puck founding partner Matt Belloni takes you inside the business of Hollywood, using exclusive reporting and insight to explain
the backstories on everything from Marvel movies to the streaming wars.
|
|
|
Puck’s daily art market email, anchored by industry expert Marion Maneker, offers unparalleled access to the mega-auctions and
galleries, elite buyers and sellers, and the power players who run this opaque world. Wall Power also features Julie Brener Davich, a veteran of Christie’s and Sotheby’s, who provides unique insights into how the business really works.
|
|
|
Need help? Review our
FAQ page or contact us for assistance. For brand partnerships, email ads@puck.news.
You received this email because you signed up to receive emails from Puck, or as part of your Puck account associated with {{customer.email}}. To stop receiving this newsletter and/or manage all your email preferences, click here.
|
Puck is published by Heat Media LLC. 107 Greenwich St., New York, NY 10006
|
|
|
|