A MESSAGE FROM OUR SPONSOR

Puck sponsors include television’s biggest phenomenon

LANDMAN

Billy Bob Thornton, Demi Moore, Andy Garcia, Ali Larter, and Sam Elliott return for the explosive second season of Taylor Sheridan's cultural phenomenon. Actor Award-nominated for Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series, The Wrap calls it "one of the best TV shows of the year" and Esquire says "this season is better than ever."

For Your Consideration in all categories, including Best Drama Series.

Now Streaming on Paramount+

EXPLORE MORE

And now, here’s Scott…

After last weekend’s box office results, there is a temptation to declare the dawn of a new world order. Two low-budget horror movies, directed by young first-time filmmakers with YouTube roots, dominated the domestic multiplex, while The Mandalorian and Grogu stumbled. Matt covered the seismic implications earlier this week, but before Hollywood fully commits to the HollyTube thesis, it’s worth looking closer at the success of each film, as well as Markiplier’s (real name: Mark Fischbach) recent Iron Lung, to determine what practical lessons the studios can learn before the greenlights start shining.

The truth is that this dynamic is more complex than a narrative in which a new form of blockbuster-quality I.P. is out there just waiting to be harvested. Instead, we’re getting the emerging pages of a playbook for identifying the sort of new media talents who have legit crossover appeal.

As studios inevitably turn to YouTube in search of new—and, yes, cheaper—talent, the most important distinction isn’t between creators with big followings and those with small ones. It’s between those with passive audiences and those with highly engaged fans.

Indeed, Fischbach’s greatest achievement might not have been making sci-fi/horror flick Iron Lung for a mere $3 million, but persuading a chunk of his 38.7 million YouTube subscribers to pressure theaters into booking the movie on more screens. In the end, he mobilized a fandom to actually show up on opening weekend. Kane Parsons wasn’t self-distributing Backrooms, but he and A24 nevertheless converted a dedicated online fandom into butts-in-seats ticket sales.

But for every Markiplier or Parsons, there are hundreds of creators with massive followings whose subscribers have demonstrated no particular inclination to leave the house. Chris Stuckmann boasts more than 2 million YouTube subscribers, but his Neon-distributed horror film, Shelby Oaks, earned just $8.1 million earlier this year. (Yes, that’s an objectively fine take considering the $1.5 million budget, but you get the point.) Kris Collins has more than 50 million TikTok followers, but her found-footage chiller, House of Eden, earned just $313,000 after debuting on 600 screens last August.

This shouldn’t be much of a surprise. Finding success on a new platform after achieving glory on another has been a long-standing, existential challenge for the entertainment industry. When it comes to TV stars blossoming into movie stars, sometimes you’re George Clooney and sometimes you’re David Caruso or Taylor Kitsch. Hollywood’s challenge isn’t finding YouTube talent—it’s finding the exceedingly rare ones whose fans treat them like a rock band.

Hollywood should be studying Obsession’s performance with equal attention. YouTube sketch comic Curry Barker’s $750,000 film just crossed $110 million domestic, becoming the second-highest U.S. earner ever (sans inflation) to cost less than $1 million to produce. More remarkably, the Focus Features release became the first wide opener outside the Christmas corridor since E.T.: The Extra-Terrestrial to increase its grosses in both its second and third weekends. (The closest comparison is Terrifier 2, which did so on around 700 screens in the fall of 2022.)

A MESSAGE FROM OUR SPONSOR

Puck sponsors include the record-breaking Paramount+ Drama Series

THE MADISON

From executive producer Taylor Sheridan.

Michelle Pfeiffer shines in this epic drama about resilience, transformation and the family ties that bind.

Variety proclaims, “Michelle Pfeiffer gives a powerhouse performance” in a show RogerEbert.com calls “rock-solid, gripping television.” Emmy eligible in all categories including, Outstanding Drama Series, Outstanding Lead Actress Michelle Pfeiffer, Outstanding Supporting Actor Kurt Russell, Outstanding Guest Actor Will Arnett and Outstanding Director Christina Alexandra Voros

Now Streaming on Paramount+

EXPLORE MORE

None of that happens without a TIFF premiere, genuine critical buzz, and an acquisition by Focus. Barker didn’t conquer Hollywood by circumvention; he moved through it. Audiences didn’t need to know his YouTube filmography to enjoy the film. Ditto A24’s success with its 2023 Sundance pickup Talk to Me, which worked for audiences who had absolutely no knowledge of Michael and Danny Philippou’s prior short films. In other words, there may be an emerging template of success coalescing around online origins, a proper industry pathway, collaboration with existing production and distribution outlets like Blumhouse-Atomic Monster, and obviously a product that stands on its own. Indeed, this was also the case with Backrooms, which works as a Lynch-ian meditation on middle age and squandered potential amid economic insecurity, even for viewers who have no knowledge of the source material or the online mythology.

The rise of YouTube filmmakers within horror isn’t a revolution so much as the natural consequence of the genre’s economics—and its unusually robust promotional opportunities. As you know, horror doesn’t require massive budgets, A-list stars, or preexisting franchises to generate returns, which makes it attractive to both first-time directors and risk-averse studios. It also benefits from a media ecosystem with no real equivalent in other genres. Outlets like Fangoria, Bloody Disgusting, and Dead Meat Presents perform a promotional function—building awareness, stoking enthusiasm, creating event-movie energy—that simply doesn't exist for a romantic comedy or a drama.

Aggressive promotional efforts and shrewd marketing campaigns aside, that genre-specific ecosystem amplified Longlegs, Weapons, Smile, and Obsession in ways that a conventional P&A campaign couldn’t have manufactured on its own. But whether this emerging generation of creators can expand beyond horror remains genuinely unclear. However, there are worse ways to spend money than throwing relatively responsible amounts of it at promising online comedy talent and letting them make actual comedies.

The weekend was also another robust rebuke to a decade of bad-faith rhetoric from Wall Street analysts and Silicon Valley evangelists who insisted that theatrical exhibition was a relic of a bygone era and only they understood younger audiences. The generation supposedly too online for movie theaters, and too distracted for anything longer than a TikTok, has been showing up in force whenever Hollywood offers something it actually wants. That may not be a weekly routine, as it was for Boomers, but the channel hasn’t evaporated either.

What’s changed isn’t young people’s appetite for cinema. It’s the social context around it. Many of the traditional third spaces—malls, bookstores, gaming centers—have contracted, closed or become overly regulated. Concurrently, younger audiences are less inclined, even when they’re old enough, to socialize around alcohol. For a generation shaped by pandemic isolation, a movie theater remains one of the few widely available venues for genuine shared experience. Yes, streaming ushered massive convenience into our lives, but the comparative paucity of theatrical releases has let many to overstate the decline of the value of theaters for younger generations.

Backrooms, Obsession, and Iron Lung didn’t succeed by replacing or renouncing theatrical exhibition. Instead, their creators embraced it, and viewed the notion of one of their movies playing globally in multiplexes as a career affirmation. Moreover, Parsons, Barker, and Fischbach all demonstrated that a nationwide theatrical release remains perhaps the most effective vehicle for galvanizing an online following for an aspiring monocultural event.

In a hopeful sign, a decade of consolidation, disruption discourse, and streaming-era triumphalism hasn’t changed what the phrase “now a major motion picture” still signals to the people who matter most—the audience. An aspiring content creator can build a following on YouTube. But it still means something to a younger generation when people are watching their stuff on a Friday night in the dark, together.

Thanks, Scott. I’ll see everyone tomorrow.

Matt

Need help? Review our FAQ page or contact us for assistance. For brand partnerships, email ads@puck.news.

You received this email because you signed up to receive emails from Puck, or as part of your Puck account associated with {{customer.email}}. To stop receiving this newsletter and/or manage all your email preferences, click here.

Puck is published by Heat Media LLC. 107 Greenwich St., New York, NY 10006