• HOLLYWOOD
  • WALL STREET
  • SILICON VALLEY
  • WASHINGTON
  • MEDIA
  • FASHION
Get 1 free article
RECENT AUTHORS
  • Julia Alexander
  • Tina Nguyen
  • Theodore Schleifer

  • Sign In
  • Join Puck
  • Newsletters
  • Authors
  • Podcasts
  • Sign In
  • Join Puck

The Rainmaker

Hi, I’m Eriq Gardner. 

 

Welcome back to The Rainmaker, my new private email at Puck focused on the underbelly of the legal industry: the most influential lawyers, most incredible lawsuits, and the power players in Hollywood, Silicon Valley, Washington, and Wall Street who are leveraging the courts to reshape industry and culture.

 

The Rainmaker will be free for the next few weeks, before becoming available only to paid Puck subscribers. If you haven’t already subscribed, or if this email was forwarded to you, click here to get on my list. 

 

In today’s email: Malibu super lawyer-producer Marc Toberoff, Hollywood superagent Ari Emanuel, and Jason Blum, Les Moonves, LeBron James, and the Superman heirs, among others. 

 

But first…

Hot on the Docket

I previously wrote about the Fair Act, which is pending in California and would, in its current form, prevent employers from locking up talent on an exclusive basis. There’s a committee hearing tomorrow, and I don’t think this audacious act of progressive lawmaking is getting the attention it truly deserves. So let me throw out this teaser: Now that the L.A. Lakers failed to make the playoffs, what is stopping LeBron James from joining a rival squad? If your answer is his Lakers contract or NBA bylaws, well, you might want to tune into that hearing.

Elon Musk

Hollywood’s Marvel-Disney Horror Story

Fifty years ago, Washington created a legal time bomb that allows the creators behind everything from Robocop and Beetlejuice to The Avengers multiverse to terminate their copyright grants and renegotiate. Welcome to the I.P. apocalypse.

Eriq Gardner

ERIQ GARDNER

I have a horror story to share. It’s about The Thing, and the shapeshifting monster that promises to devour much of Hollywood. Studios are now bracing for mass casualties. But there’s more to this bloody story. 

 

This tale begins in the 1970s, when federal lawmakers added decades to the lifespan of copyrights. Sounds straightforward, but there was a twist. It was also decided that authors of copyrighted works (and their heirs) should enjoy the newly lengthened term rather than publishers and studios. Why? Congress knew that many creatives possess little bargaining power early in their careers and they often assign rights for very little. The idea was to give them a second bite at the apple. These creators would have to wait a while (35 years for works created after 1978; 56 years for older works), but once the ticking clock hits the mark, these individuals can terminate copyright grants and reclaim ownership.

 

Guess what? That clock is now running out for a plethora of properties, as my colleague Matt Belloni wrote this past week. Amazon shouldn’t feel too bad about spending $8.5 billion for a leaky I.P. studio like MGM, which is primed in the next few months to lose both Robocop and Hannibal Lecter, and then next year, One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, Hoosiers, and Logan’s Run. Indeed, a trip to the Copyright Office reveals that expiring rights are a growing phenomenon across the industry. According to records, Sony is facing termination on Bad Boys while Paramount is facing the situation on Grease and Belloni’s all-time favorite movie, Mommie Dearest. Warner Bros. has received termination notices for Nightmare on Elm Street, Beetlejuice, and Ace Ventura. Disney has Mrs. Doubtfire, Who Framed Roger Rabbit?, and partial ownership of most of the Marvel superheroes (more on that in a second). And outside the major studios, everything from the musical variety show Soul Train to the infamous ‘70s porn classic Deep Throat are in play.

 

Not all these franchises will end up reclaimed by script authors. What often happens—this is especially common in the music industry—is that a termination notice becomes a prelude to a negotiation. The creator might agree to a new grant of rights to the studio (or record label or publisher) in exchange for a fatter royalty check. Or, sometimes, the studio will put up a fight, arguing that a property isn’t eligible for termination for this or that reason. 

 

No surprise, then, that this aspect of the entertainment industry invites the involvement of both dealmakers and litigators (not to mention divorce lawyers and probate specialists). For instance, on Friday, in a lawsuit alleging that Universal Music Group is systematically and improperly rejecting termination notices, recording artists asked a federal judge to certify a class action. Here’s the memorandum they filed, helpfully forwarded to me by a keen observer. (I had already seen this one, but I nevertheless appreciate comments and tips. Email me at eriq@puck.news.) 

 

All of this brings me to a Malibu lawyer named Marc Toberoff, who has made a career off of arguably knowing more about the termination provisions of copyright law than anyone else. Plus, quite importantly, he keeps a good calendar. He recently scored a massive win, representing Friday the 13th screenwriter Victor Miller in a landmark court battle against the horror franchise’s producer Sean Cunningham. He successfully argued the screenplay was not a work made for hire and thus eligible for termination. 

 

Toberoff is now seeking to achieve something similar for the heirs of some Marvel freelancers from the 1960s who helped create iconic characters such as Iron Man, Spider-Man, Dr. Strange, Ant-Man, Hawkeye, Black Widow, Falcon, Thor and others. Last September, Disney filed suit in federal court in an attempt to hold on to full control of Avengers characters, and it’s no exaggeration to say that the outcome is worth billions of dollars.

 

Toberoff is a pretty unusual lawyer. Just check out his IMDB page, where he is a credited producer on the remakes of I Spy, Piranha, Roots, and most recently, Hellraiser. How did he pull this off? Well, he works on contingency, and that can fee be structured so he shares in his clients’ copyright successes, meaning their post-termination licensing endeavors. He’s now lawyer slash producer Marc Toberoff, thank you very much.

 

What will Toberoff’s stake be if he beats Disney? I don’t know the answer for sure, but I can surmise he’ll end up becoming an important and controversial player. That’s because I’ve been paying attention to The Thing.

Earlier this century, Toberoff achieved notoriety in a copyright termination fight over Superman. At one point in the long-running court battle, DC Comics filed claims against a company that Toberoff co-founded with Endeavor C.E.O. Ari Emanuel for allegedly manipulating the heirs of Joe Shuster and Jerry Siegel, and interfering with the comic studio’s Superman contracts. A judge later ruled this claim had come too late, and Toberoff defended the contingency relationship at the time as “proper.”

 

I mention this because Toberoff quietly filed his own suit last summer where he alleges tortious interference. Until 2018, Toberoff was representing the heirs of John W. Campbell, Jr., who wrote the novel Who Goes There?, which was the basis for Universal’s 1982 and 2011 horror films entitled The Thing. Toberoff was successful in recapturing the rights, and he took a 50 percent stake in the property thanks to his fee arrangement. Later, he alleges, Blumhouse Productions (the Jason Blum company that has overseen such horror hits as Get Out, Paranormal Activity, and The Purge) tendered a “lowball offer” to option those rights. Toberoff countered by requesting a portion of Blumhouse’s profit participation from the lucrative deal it has with Universal. No dice. 

 

What happened next, according to Toberoff’s suit, is that several individuals got involved—including Alan Donnes, a small-time producer who once ran National Lampoon before dying in 2020—and they started making disparaging comments about him to his clients. It was all part of an “illicit scheme,” Toberoff alleges, to manipulate his clients to fire him and remake The Thing with Blumhouse/Universal for a cheaper price. 

 

Even by Hollywood standards, this is a pretty wild case—and a sign of how valuable even B-level I.P. is these days. In November, a Los Angeles judge rejected part of the suit and left some clues that Toberoff’s remaining claims might ultimately not survive the statute of limitations. The dispute is now headed to a California appeals court.

 

Meanwhile, the Marvel heroes case is heating up. Disney is represented by Daniel Petrocelli, the same attorney who once successfully defended DC’s continued ability to make Superman movies—and who is currently representing CNN against Chris Cuomo—and Toberoff has been privately updating Emanuel about it. Endeavor denies that it has a direct stake in the litigation over Iron Man and his buddies, although the company boasted in its first-ever amicus brief at the Supreme Court late last year that it has a “growing practice representing the estates and heirs of creators.” (Read here.) Speaking up about a copyright termination situation, WME urged the high court to adopt an interpretation of “work for hire” that would benefit creators rather than studios (and would be a disastrous development for Disney and its new C.E.O. Bob Chapek). The justices declined to take up the case—probably a disappointment for the survivors of the termination apocalypse.

 

Disney and Toberoff will now litigate the issue of whether Marvel’s freelancers contributed characters as works made for hire. That will entail an investigation into the 1960s-era working conditions for the comic house’s authors and illustrators. Even if a district judge rules in Disney’s favor that these characters are not eligible for termination, the battle will continue on appeal where Toberoff will insist that lower courts are using the wrong legal standards under old copyright law. How am I sure? That’s exactly what happened a decade ago in his case involving comic book legend Jack Kirby. In fact, Petrocelli has already drawn in his firm’s appellate attorneys to the newest case in anticipation of this coming stage of the fight.

 

Back in 2014, the Kirby termination case got to the Supreme Court’s doorstep whereupon Disney settled it for tens of millions of dollars rather than take the small chance the justices would intervene. It’s easy to imagine, with so much at stake, that Disney would make a similar offer.

 

But would Toberoff accept? That amount of money would be hard to turn down, and he certainly would have an obligation to proceed in his clients’ best interests. Then again, the incentive of a lawyer working on contingency is a fascinating issue. And being a producer on a Marvel blockbuster has got to be awfully tempting.

Decision of the Week

 

Is virtual reality a public space? On Friday, in Dylan Panarra v. HTC Corporation, U.S. District Court Judge Frank Gerachi, Jr., ruled that devicemaker HTC must face a lawsuit over the lack of closed captioning on its virtual reality subscription service, Viveport Infinity. The complaint comes from a deaf individual who is invoking the American with Disabilities Act. In seeking a dismissal, HTC argued that Viveport is “software” and not tied to a physical location. 

 

That web-only businesses have obligations under the ADA has been a controversial topic in many cases, and just last month, the Department of Justice released guidance that websites must be accessible to those with disabilities. Here, the New York federal judge applied other recent ADA cases involving digital sites and rules that the plaintiff had adequately alleged that virtual reality is a place of public accommodation too. The judge also wouldn’t allow HTC’s argument that it lacks control over VR content to stop the case from moving forward. Read the full opinion here.

Also on the Docket…

 

– In February, I wrote about a new federal law that prevents sexual misconduct claims from being forced into arbitration. Specifically, I said CNN could face a lawsuit arising from the Jeff Zucker–Allison Gollust situation but maybe Fox News will test the new law before CNN. That’s because Andrea Tantaros, a former co-host of The Five who has been pressing a sexual harassment complaint for seemingly forever, is now invoking the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act. On April 11, Fox told a judge that the new law won’t apply retroactively, that the plain language doesn’t apply to something that happened six years ago. Here’s the Fox News filing.

 

– Photographers are lining up against Jay-Z in a suit the hip hop star is pursuing against Jonathan Mannion, the shutterbug who snapped the image that adorns the cover of Reasonable Doubt, his highly acclaimed first album. Mannion has licensed images from the shoot for merchandise—and in response, Jay-Z claims a violation of his right of publicity. Mannion argues the claim is preempted by copyright law and flouts the First Amendment. The suit is now due for a summary judgment ruling—and, recognizing the importance of the case, several photographer associations have submitted an amicus brief. I.P. professors have one too. The hearing is set for May 16.

 

– Legal briefs: The soap opera saga that is California’s case over sexual harassment at Activision Blizzard has taken yet another turn, with a resignation and an accusation of meddling by Governor Gavin Newsom … As I first reported, CBS has resolved shareholder litigation over failing to disclose the #MeToo problems of former C.E.O. Leslie Moonves. A motion for approval submitted on Friday reveals the settlement is worth $14.75 million … The U.S.F.L. has returned? The football league, showcasing televised games this past weekend, is likely infringing a trademark, but according to a judge in a rather unusual decision, there’s just too much money invested to stop it from appearing on network television … And finally, Johnny Depp is set to testify tomorrow in his U.S. libel lawsuit against ex Amber Heard. Set your DVR for Court TV….

FOUR STORIES WE’RE TALKING ABOUT

cocktail

The Murdoch Empire

M.I.A. Murdoch, the possible home of Sunday Ticket, Jeopardy’s Mike Richards, the future of WarnerMedia’s TV assets, and more.

MATTHEW BELLONI

ufo

Twitter’s Panic Room

Musk is serious about buying Twitter. The company’s board, Goldman, and its management team better get serious, too. 

WILLIAM D. COHAN

card

The Maddow Apocalypse

Puck co-founder Jon Kelly joins Peter to discuss MSNBC’s vexing inactivity to plug its Maddow-sized hole in prime time.

PETER HAMBY

money bag

Woke War III

Pence’s attempt to get canceled, Trump’s latest endorsement fool’s errand, and a head-scratching story of a fallen meme-lord dynasty.

TINA NGUYEN

 

swash divider

Facebook Twitter Instagram LinkedIn

You received this message because you signed up to receive emails from Puck.

 

Was this email forwarded to you?

Sign up for Puck here

 

Sent to

 

Interested in exploring our newsletter offerings?
Manage your preferences

 

Puck is published by Heat Media LLC.
64 Bank Street
New York, NY 10014

 

For support, just reply to this e-mail.

For brand partnerships, email ads@puck.news

SEE THE ARCHIVES

SHARE
Try Puck for free

Sign up today to join the inside conversation at the nexus of Wall Street, Washington, Silicon Valley, Hollywood, and more.

Already a member? Sign In


  • Daily articles and breaking news
  • Personal emails directly from our authors
  • Gift subscriber-only stories to friends & family
  • Unlimited access to archives
  • Bookmark articles to create a Reading List

  • Off the record conference calls with authors and staff
  • Invites to exclusive in-person events
  • Early access to new editorial and product features
  • Exclusive access to Puck merch
  • Premium podcast content

Exclusive to Inner Circle only

Latest Articles from Hollywood

For WBD C.E.O. David Zaslav, almost anything is up for grabs if it generates the revenue needed to pay down the company’s whopping $47.5 billion in debt.
Julia Alexander • September 26, 2023
Zaz’s Sports Moneyball
Warner Discovery C.E.O. David Zaslav will begin streaming NBA, NHL, and MLB games exclusively on its Bleacher Report add-on to Max. But don’t expect everything to suddenly change overnight.
A federal judge has ordered Netflix to trial over Ava DuVernay’s ‘When They See Us,’ a 2019 docudrama about the notorious Central Park jogger case.
Eriq Gardner • September 25, 2023
The Ava DuVernay/Netflix Suit No One Talks About
Inside the complex libel fight over the portrayal of Linda Fairstein, the prosecutor-turned-novelist, in the acclaimed Central Park Five film, ‘When They See Us.’ Could this impact the streamers’ risk tolerance, and the future of docudramas?
The studios made it clear that if there wasn’t a deal this weekend—and preferably before the Yom Kippur sundown—they were planning to move on to SAG-AFTRA.
Matthew Belloni & Jonathan Handel • September 25, 2023
Hollywood’s Post-Writers Strike Reality
Both sides claim victory as the 146-day impasse ends, the actors wait in the wings, and the next weeks and months come into focus. A sigh of relief in Hollywood, yet there are reasons to believe this aftermath will look very different.
Lachlan, James, Anna and Rupert Murdoch in New York City, 1987.
Matthew Belloni • September 22, 2023
Murdoch’s Audience of Two
Was Rupert’s ‘retirement’ notice intended to signify his ride off into the sunset or denote his full-blown support of Lachlan—or, more likely, was it meant for an audience of his daughters, Liz and Prue, whose votes may control the family trust?
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA - NOVEMBER 18: Disney Executive Chairman Bob Iger attends the Exclusive 100-Minute Sneak Peek of Peter Jackson's The Beatles: Get Back at El Capitan Theatre on November 18, 2021 in Hollywood, California. (Photo by Charley Gallay/Getty Images for Disney)
Julia Alexander • September 19, 2023
Reflections on the Disney-Charter Hostage Crisis
What we did, and didn’t, learn from the carriage fee negotiation heard round the world.
Drew Barrymore
Matthew Belloni • September 17, 2023
Social Media Has Already Won the Strike
The Drew Barrymore saga perfectly encapsulates an underappreciated aspect of this labor impasse. Online discourse hasn’t necessarily dictated what the studios will agree to, but it’s unquestionably offered the WGA leadership more leverage.
From the beginning, Costner has seen Yellowstone as The Kevin Costner Show, even as its headstrong co-creator and showrunner Taylor Sheridan has maintained ultimate control and the backing of Paramount.
Matthew Belloni • September 14, 2023
Kevin Costner Spent His Strike Summer Fighting Over ‘Yellowstone’
Costner’s threat to sue over his likely exit from TV’s top show comes after months of back-and-forth with Paramount, a rep’s hasty trip to New York, and a call with Taylor Sheridan that did not go well.


Get access to this story

Enter your email for a free preview of Puck’s full offering, including exclusive articles, private emails from authors, and more.

Verify your email and sign in by clicking the link we just sent.

Already a member? Sign In


Start 14 Day Free Trial for Unlimited Access Instead →

Latest Articles from Hollywood

Israeli hits like ‘Fauda‘ are certainly finding new audiences in the U.S., but the foreign genre generally isn’t as popular as English language series.
Julia Alexander • September 12, 2023
Lost in Translation
As Hollywood engages in its grueling labor war, and production grinds to a halt, studios and streamers are turning to a workaround: internationally-produced scripted and unscripted series. Will it work?
AMPTP president Carol Lombardini.
Jonathan Handel • September 11, 2023
Will the AMPTP Crack?
With the dual strikes causing real damage and the companies pursuing divergent goals, holding the Hollywood management alliance together may be impossible.
Ken Griffin is locked in a nasty behind-the-scenes legal fight with Sony Pictures over his depiction in ‘Dumb Money.’
Matthew Belloni • September 11, 2023
Ken Griffin’s Secret War on ‘Dumb Money’
The hedge fund billionaire is locked in a nasty behind-the-scenes legal fight over his depiction in the new GameStop movie and has hired at least two separate law firms to send Sony Pictures threatening letters—one of which I obtained.
In finding a synergistic private buyer in François-Henri Pinaul, whose $40 billion in assets include Kering and Christie’s, TPG managed to thread the needle.
Matthew Belloni • September 8, 2023
Parlez-Vous CAA?
A French fashion player announces himself in Hollywood as the talent agency’s private equity backers prove that, even if the sky appears to be falling, you can still make a lot of money in this town.
AMC’s deal with David Zaslav and WBD’s Max streamer is ostensibly premised on the notion that the network will be able to capture subscriber attention from the larger platform.
Julia Alexander • September 6, 2023
Disney, Zaz-AMC & the New Fronts in the Streaming Wars
News and notes on the hottest topics in the streaming industrial complex: Warner Discovery’s deal for AMC+ shows, the ESPN-Charter battle, and more.
Fran Drescher has ceded some of the spotlight to chief negotiator Duncan Crabtree-Ireland, who comes across as firm and determined but not ferocious.
Matthew Belloni & Jonathan Handel • September 4, 2023
The Official End-of-Summer Strike Report
A candid conversation on The Eight’s strategy, Fran Drescher’s whereabouts, why Bradley Cooper isn’t in Venice, the interim agreements and more as Hollywood’s summer of unrest turns into an autumn free-for-all.
In November 2021, Tatiana Spottiswoode testified before the House Judiciary Committee about her relationship with Zia Chishti, and how Chishti allegedly subjected her to humiliating situations at work and sent her disturbing emails.
Eriq Gardner • September 4, 2023
A Legal Coda to the #MeToo Era
The bizarre story of a disgraced C.E.O. attempting to win back his reputation. It’s a plot that involves former lawyers for Harvey Weinstein and Gretchen Carlson, landmark legislation, Congress, and more.

You have 1 free article Left

To read this full story and more, start your 14 day free trial today →


Already a member? Sign In

  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Contact
  • FAQ
© 2023 Heat Media All rights reserved.
Become a member

All of the insider knowledge from our top tier authors, in your inbox.

Sign up

Already a member? Sign In

Verify your email!

You should receive a link to log in at .

I DID NOT RECEIVE A LINK

Didn't get an email? Check your spam folder and confirm the spelling of your email, and try again. If you continue to have trouble, reach out to fritz@puck.news.

SIGN UP with Google
SIGN UP with Google
SIGN UP with Apple
SIGN UP with Apple
OR USE EMAIL & PASSWORD
Password strength:

OR
Sign in

Not a member yet? Sign up today

Sign in with Google
Sign in with Google
Sign in with Apple
Sign in with Apple
OR USE EMAIL & PASSWORD
Don't have a password or need to reset it?

OR
Verify Account

Verify your email!

You should receive a link to log in at .

I DID NOT RECEIVE A LINK

Didn't get an email? Check your spam folder and confirm the spelling of your email, and try again. If you continue to have trouble, reach out to fritz@puck.news.

YOUR EMAIL

Use a different sign in option instead

Member Exclusive

Try Puck for free

Use our promo code: DOUBLEDOWN


  • Daily articles and breaking news
  • Personal emails directly from our authors
  • Premium podcast content
Welcome to Puck!

You are logged into a free account as unknown@example.com

Already a member? Sign in with your paid account


Directly Supporting Authors

A new economic model in which writers are also partners in the business.

Personalized Subscriptions

Customize your settings to receive the newsletters you want from the authors you follow.

Stay in the Know

Connect directly with Puck talent through email and exclusive events.